DEPARTMENTSIX

BMW Z4 E85 2.5i vs 3.0i Manual: Sold Prices, Nov 2026

Six manual E85 Z4 roadsters, 2.5i and 3.0i from 2003 to 2005, with sold prices, recalls and inspection checks.

By Department Six Published Buyer's Guide
Black BMW E85 Z4 roadster with the top up, front three-quarter view
Photo: Ethan Llamas, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Some links in this article go to car listing and parts sites. Some of them may be affiliate links, which means Department Six may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Details are on our affiliate disclosure page.

Prices checked November 2026.

The early BMW Z4 roadster came with the same M54 six-cylinder family in 2 sizes: a 2.5-liter with 184 hp and a 3.0-liter with 225 hp, according to BMW. The 2.5i came with a 5-speed manual and the 3.0i with a 6-speed. This guide covers 6 cars, the 2.5i and 3.0i in 2003, 2004 and 2005, with sold prices from the past 3 months, NHTSA recalls and what to check. We give a range only with 3 or more matching sales, and we label every figure sold, market value or asking. Our broader Z4 buying guide covers later cars.

Recent sales and market

Market value (classic.com): classic.com 2.5i page shows $10,888 for the E85 2.5i and the classic.com 3.0i page shows $12,451 for the 3.0i. Its sold-and-manual filter lists 11 sales of the 2.5i averaging $10,395 and 18 sales of the 3.0i averaging $13,727 over the past year. 3 of those 3.0i sales are 2007 cars, so we do not use that average for 2003 to 2005.

Sold (auctions): the table lists every manual 2003 to 2005 sale we could open on Bring a Trailer and Cars and Bids from September to November 2026, with the transmission read from each listing. Several listings with plausible titles were automatics or SMG cars, and we left them out.

CarSold priceDateSource
2003 2.5i$8,000Oct 28, 2026Bring a Trailer, 35,000 miles
2003 2.5i$6,650Sep 14, 2026Cars and Bids, 91,200 miles
2003 3.0i$18,750Oct 21, 2026Bring a Trailer, 49,000 miles
2003 3.0i$15,000Sep 12, 2026Bring a Trailer, 40,000 miles
2003 3.0i$12,500Sep 30, 2026Bring a Trailer, 49,000 miles
2003 3.0i$10,650Oct 8, 2026Cars and Bids, 40,000 miles
2004 3.0i$15,250Oct 29, 2026Bring a Trailer, 41,000 miles
2004 3.0i$14,400Nov 9, 2026Bring a Trailer, 48,000 miles
2004 3.0i$10,500Nov 14, 2026Bring a Trailer, 72,000 miles
2004 3.0i$13,100Nov 12, 2026Cars and Bids, 57,200 miles, supercharged

We found no 2005 2.5i or 3.0i auction sale in this window. classic.com tracked a 19,000-mile 2005 2.5i auction at $17,500 in August 2026 and a 61,000-mile 2005 3.0i at $13,375, but neither has a page we can link, so we treat them as single-source context.

Asking (CarGurus): nationwide, CarGurus lists 169 Z4 roadsters from 2003 to 2005, 104 in the 2.5i Roadster RWD trim and 65 in the 3.0i Roadster RWD trim. CarGurus shows no market value for these years, so we use it for supply only.

The sources disagree on the 2.5i. classic.com puts its market value at $10,888, but the 2 recent clean sales we found brought $6,650 and $8,000, about 25% to 40% lower. A 2004 2.5i with 51,000 miles also sold for $8,500 on Cars and Bids in July 2026. For the 3.0i, classic.com's $12,451 market value sits inside the $10,500 to $18,750 auction spread.

Which early Z4 manual is right for you?

  • Most buyers: a 3.0i. It has 41 more horsepower, 39 more lb-ft and a 6-speed, and BMW quoted 5.9 seconds to 60 mph against 7.1 for the 2.5i.
  • Lowest price: a 2.5i. Recent sales were $6,650 to $8,000, but we found only 2, so check each car on its own.
  • Best documented market: a 2004 3.0i. 3 unmodified sales, $10,500 to $15,250, plus 1 supercharged car at $13,100.

2.5i and 3.0i differences by model year

Item2.5i3.0i
Engine2.5-liter inline-63.0-liter inline-6
Power and torque184 hp, 175 lb-ft225 hp, 214 lb-ft
Manual gearbox5-speed6-speed
0 to 60 mph, BMW 2003 figure7.1 seconds5.9 seconds

The figures come from the BMW 2003 Z4 price release and Road and Track. BMW noted the 6-speed manual was available from December 2002 production, so a very early 2003 3.0i may differ. For 2005, Edmunds lists the 2.5i with a 5-speed manual and the 3.0i with a 6-speed.

The 6 cars

Each section lists the sold manual cars we found, NHTSA recalls for the model year and a CarGurus search. Recalls are tied to VINs, so run the VIN to see which are open.

1. 2003 BMW Z4 2.5i roadster, 5-speed manual

Price check: 2 clean sales, $6,650 and $8,000, which is not enough for a range. A 10,000-mile SCCA race car also sold for $9,200 in September 2026, but it is not a typical street car.

  • NHTSA lists 4 campaigns for 2003 Z4s: 03V032 (front belt buckle connection to the tensioner cable), 04V182 (fuel pump vapor lock that could stall the engine), 03V214 (tires on cars with 18-inch wheels possibly damaged during mounting) and 04V247 (incompatible air bag processors). NHTSA recall data, 2003 Z4.

2. 2004 BMW Z4 2.5i roadster, 5-speed manual

Price check: we found no sale from September to November 2026. The nearest is the 51,000-mile car that sold for $8,500 in July, one sale, so there is no range.

3. 2005 BMW Z4 2.5i roadster, 5-speed manual

Price check: 1 sale, a 19,000-mile car at $17,500 in August 2026 per classic.com. That is one low-mileage outlier, not a market price.

4. 2003 BMW Z4 3.0i roadster, 6-speed manual

Price check: 4 sold manual cars, $10,650 to $18,750, from 40,000 to 49,000 miles. Bring a Trailer sold cars at $18,750, $15,000 and $12,500 and Cars and Bids sold one at $10,650. The spread is wide even at similar mileage, so condition and options decide it.

5. 2004 BMW Z4 3.0i roadster, 6-speed manual

Price check: 3 unmodified sales from Bring a Trailer, $10,500 (72,000 miles), $14,400 (48,000) and $15,250 (41,000), so $10,500 to $15,250. A supercharged car with 57,200 miles brought $13,100. Price follows mileage here.

6. 2005 BMW Z4 3.0i roadster, 6-speed manual

Price check: 1 sale, a 61,000-mile car at $13,375 in August 2026 per classic.com. One sale is not a range.

Equipment and options worth seeking

The Sport package includes Dynamic Driving Control, a button that firms up steering and sharpens throttle response, per Automobile Magazine. For the 3.0i, European Car describes a staggered 18-inch wheel setup with 225/40R18 front and 255/35R18 rear tires. Check the window sticker or build data to see which equipment a car left the factory with.

Service history and inspection priorities

  • Recalls. Run the VIN for the campaigns above, especially the fuel pump (04V182) and air bag processor (04V247) work.
  • Steering. The Z4 uses electric power steering with no power steering fluid, according to BMW service information. Check for smooth, even assist on a test drive.
  • Tires. All Z4s came with run-flat tires and no spare, per the same document. Ask what is fitted and whether a spare or repair kit is carried.
  • Engine. These are M54 engines. Our guides cover the crankcase vent, DISA valve and oil filter housing gasket.
  • Roof. We could not open a BMW or NHTSA document on roof faults for these years, so we do not list any. Cycle the top several times and check for leaks, a torn rear window and slow or uneven motion.

What to check on a test drive

  • Clutch take-up, and that every gear engages cleanly.
  • Steering that feels even in both directions.
  • Temperature gauge steady after a long drive.
  • No hesitation or stalling when warm, which is what recall 04V182 describes.

Final buying checklist

  • Run the VIN through NHTSA and a BMW center for open campaigns.
  • Ask for service records, including cooling system and clutch work.
  • Confirm the gearbox by the 5 or 6 forward gears and the paperwork, since automatics and SMG cars are also common.
  • Get an independent pre-purchase inspection.

How we picked

The brief we started from listed 6 cars: the 2.5i and 3.0i roadster in 2003, 2004 and 2005. We kept all 6 after checking BMW and Edmunds for the manual gearbox in each. We read Bring a Trailer and Cars and Bids sales from September to November 2026 and checked the transmission on each, read classic.com market values and sold rows, and used CarGurus only for listing counts. We could not open BMW factory literature for roof or cooling issues and did not use forum reports. We found no correctly matched licensed photo that separates a 2.5i from a 3.0i, so the cars have no per-car photos.

Related Department Six pages

Add Department Six as a preferred source on Google